The Best Way to Explore Lunar Craters Is a Giant Robot Ball
On a good day, the rock quarry in central Texas is about 370,000 kilometers (230,000 miles) from the moon. But last February, when Rishi Jangale watched his 1.8-meter-wide, 150-kilogram inflatable robot roll effortlessly over rocks, gravel, and wet clay, his imagination turned the quarry into the lunar surface instead.Jangale is an upbeat mechanical engineer nearing the end of his Ph.D at Texas A&M University, in College Station, TX. He and his labmates have been working on this big tan “RoboBall” for about five years. Their goal: create a vehicle capable of exploring some of the most inaccessible terrain in our solar system, such as the 21 km-wide Shackleton Crater on the moon’s south pole.Shackleton crater is 4 km deep and contains many smaller, deeper craters within. Some parts of the crater never see the sun, and within these perpetually dark, frigid pockets lie mysterious substances that planetary scientists have long struggled to examine, including layers of ancient lunar geology and stores of frozen water that could potentially support a future lunar base.“The moon is like an archive of what happened to the Earth,” says Sara Russell, a cosmic mineralogist with London’s Natural History Museum who is not involved with Texas A&M’s work. “Robotic collection works brilliantly well, and it’s great to see that being explored more in this context.”“NASA is not going to let astronauts get anywhere near these craters, because if someone falls in, you’re not going to be able to get them out,” Jangale says. “So we thought: what better shape to roll down a hill than a ball?” In a recent paper published in IEEE Transactions on Field Robotics, Jangale’s team reports on the design of RoboBall, a hypothetical lunar mission, and results from initial tests in the Texas quarry.Getting RollingRoboBall is the brainchild of Jangale’s advisor, former NASA robotics engineer Robert Ambrose, who first conceived of the design in 2003.Ambrose figured that a ball could address a pesky mobility problem that robots face on lunar terrain, especially in low gravity: tipping over. An inflatable sphere not only cannot tip over, but the form factor also insulates its internal components from sharp rocks, dust, and the huge temperature swings from over 93 °C in sunlit spots to minus 240 °C in the shade inside lunar craters. Ambrose imagined a wheeled rover parking at a crater’s edge and releasing a RoboBall to explore its depths. Unlike a small tethered rover, the RoboBall wouldn’t roll its way back up; but with no strings attached, it would have far greater range to collect geological samples, and then be able to launch them back to the rover outside the crater with small rockets. A robotic rover would ferry RoboBall across the lunar surface to the edge of a crater.R. Jangale, D. Pravecek, et al.NASA hasn’t brought lunar samples back to Earth in over 50 years. Some morsels of moon geology find their way to Earth as meteorites, but Russell says these lack the “gold standard” field work — context about where that sample actually came from. Even as NASA reboots its crewed moon missions, many lunar sites remain inaccessible.In 2022, Ambrose’s lab finished a proof-of-concept, the 0.5 meter wide RoboBall II. Creating the full-sized RoboBall III then took about 11 months. “We were building these robots really quickly,” Jangale says. “Ambrose really encourages us to use and break these robots.” And designs did go awry. Jangale remembers software errors and a drivetrain that proved too weak to roll over soft bumps in initial tests. Texas A&M RAD Lab/YouTubeHow to Slow Your RollRoboBall drives by moving a pendulum within its shell, shifting its entire center of mass. On flat ground, if the pendulum’s arm points forward, the shell rolls forward to compensate, and as long as the pendulum keeps the center of mass in front of the center of the ball, RoboBall will keep rolling forward. If the pendulum leans a few degrees to the left or right, RoboBall steers left or right to match. “The robot wants to go where you point the pendulum,” Jangale says. The 340-pound ball is just soft enough to bounce lightly over bumpy obstacles, but its slight overpressure keeps it relatively firm. On steep slopes, this mechanism also lets the ball control its downhill speed by simply angling the pendulum uphill.“The beauty here is the simplicity,” says Hiro Ono, an aerospace engineer who worked on robot mobility at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Lab for 13 years before joining Georgia Tech. For space robots, Ono describes simplicity in terms of the number of actuators. RoboBall has just two, and both are fully inside of the shell, shielded from environmental risk factors like dust, a feature that Ono describes as “unique.”After the first quarry tests, it took about seven months for the team to design and build an upgraded RoboBall III with 2.5 times more torque—enough to fling itself over small obstacles and roll up 20 degree slopes. A small rocket can launch out of the center of RoboBall to return a sample back to a rover outside of the crater.R. Jangale, D. Pravecek, et al.Getting Mission ReadyIn the new paper, the remotely-operated RoboBall III descended the quarry’s slopes, navigated soft terrain, and launched hypothetical payloads back out of the crater with small rockets. Powered by a large battery, during a lunar mission the robot would inflate itself and charge up from a robotic rover at the edge of a crater before heading out on its own.RoboBall is probably not the right platform for all kinds of missions—its slightly bumbling nature means that it’s not ideal if you want to collect a sample from a very specific rock, for example. For now, the team hopes to work with scientists designing lunar science instruments to physically fit into RoboBall’s carry-on luggage-sized interior, while also fitting in with how RoboBall operates. “The robot is not the mission,” Jangale says. “The robot is a way for you to complete the mission.”The current version of RoboBall cost roughly $250,000 to build, but is not quite ready for the moon in its current form. While its gold-treated aluminum parts are appropriate for space missions, its other materials are not. Space-grade electronics will cost more, and the ball’s shell—made from a material tough enough to roll over steel shards and withstand minus 184 °C temperatures—has never been evaluated in lunar extremes. Aside from materials questions, the team plans to engineer the ball to adapt how it drives on varying slopes autonomously. They also hope to collaborate with government agencies or spaceflight contractors to keep refining the robot’s design for a real, eventual mission.Later this year, Texas A&M will open a new facility in Houston with the world’s largest indoor simulated moon and Mars landscapes. The facility is only 190 km from Jangale’s quarry. It’s still about 370,000 km from the moon, but it’s going to help Jangale get his robot quite a bit closer.]]>
