AI chatbots can sway voters better than political advertisements
The Rise of AI Chatbots in Politics: A Game-Changer or a Threat to Democracy?
As the world becomes increasingly dependent on artificial intelligence (AI), a new frontier is emerging in the realm of politics: AI chatbots. These digital entities are being used to sway voters, shape public opinion, and even influence election outcomes. A recent study published in the journals Nature and Science has revealed that AI chatbots can be more effective than traditional political advertisements in nudging voters to support opposing candidates. But what does this mean for democracy, and how can we ensure that these powerful tools are used responsibly?
The Power of AI Chatbots
The study, conducted by a team of researchers from multiple universities, found that AI chatbots can persuade people more effectively than traditional political advertisements. This is because chatbots can generate much more information in real-time and strategically deploy it in conversations. In fact, the researchers found that one conversation with an AI chatbot can have a "pretty meaningful effect" on salient election choices.
The study involved recruiting over 2,300 participants to engage in a conversation with a chatbot two months before the 2024 US presidential election. The chatbot was trained to advocate for either one of the top two candidates, and the results were surprising. Donald Trump supporters who chatted with an AI model favoring Kamala Harris became slightly more inclined to support Harris, moving 3.9 points toward her on a 100-point scale. That was roughly four times the measured effect of political advertisements during the 2016 and 2020 elections.
The Catch: Inaccuracy and Misinformation
But here's the catch: some of the "evidence" and "facts" the chatbots presented were untrue. Across all three countries, chatbots advocating for right-leaning candidates made a larger number of inaccurate claims than those advocating for left-leaning candidates. This raises serious concerns about the potential for misinformation and the impact it could have on democracy.
The Optimized Persuasive Model
In a separate study published in Science, an overlapping team of researchers investigated what makes these chatbots so persuasive. They deployed 19 LLMs to interact with nearly 77,000 participants from the UK on more than 700 political issues while varying factors like computational power, training techniques, and rhetorical strategies. The most effective way to make the models persuasive was to instruct them to pack their arguments with facts and evidence and then give them additional training by feeding them examples of persuasive conversations.
The Cost of Truthfulness
But optimizing persuasiveness came at the cost of truthfulness. When the models became more persuasive, they increasingly provided misleading or false information—and no one is sure why. "It could be that as the models learn to deploy more and more facts, they essentially reach to the bottom of the barrel of stuff they know, so the facts get worse-quality," says Kobi Hackenburg, a research scientist at the UK AI Security Institute.
The Implications for Democracy
The emergence of AI chatbots in politics raises profound questions about the future of democracy. Will these powerful tools be used to amplify truth or fiction? Will they do more to shape public opinion or to amplify existing biases? And who will have the upper hand: politicians, voters, or the chatbots themselves?
The Need for Guardrails
As people turn to AI to help them navigate their lives, they may also start asking chatbots for voting advice whether campaigns prompt the interaction or not. That may be a troubling world for democracy, unless there are strong guardrails to keep the systems in check. Auditing and documenting the accuracy of LLM outputs in conversations about politics may be a first step.
Conclusion
The rise of AI chatbots in politics is a game-changer, but it's also a threat to democracy. As we move forward, it's essential that we prioritize truthfulness, accuracy, and transparency in the use of these powerful tools. We must ensure that AI chatbots are used responsibly and that their potential for misinformation is mitigated. The future of democracy depends on it.
Deep Dive
- Artificial intelligence: How AGI became the most consequential conspiracy theory of our time
- OpenAI's new LLM exposes the secrets of how AI really works
- Quantum physicists have shrunk and "de-censored" DeepSeek R1
- AI toys are all the rage in China—and now they're appearing on shelves in the US too
Stay Connected
Get the latest updates from MIT Technology Review:
- Discover special offers, top stories, upcoming events, and more.
- Enter your email to stay connected.
Privacy Policy
Thank you for submitting your email!
Explore more newsletters
It looks like something went wrong.
We're having trouble saving your preferences. Try refreshing this page and updating them one more time. If you continue to get this message, reach out to us at [email protected] with a list of newsletters you'd like to receive.
